The dual dubious distinctions have come as Goldman shares have continued their recent decline, falling 3.5%, or $6.86, to $191.36 amid a selloff for financial stocks. Book value stood at $197.33 a share at the end of the September quarter.
The last time Goldman traded below book was in October 2016, before Donald Trump’s election win.
Goldman shares now are down 24.9% in 2018, the worst showing among the 30 members of the Dow industrials, Bloomberg data show. IBM’s loss is the second-sharpest, at 23.6%. General Electric would be the Dow’s worst performer given its 56% decline to $7.65, but it was dropped from the index in June.
The bank didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.
Goldman shares have lost 15% in the past month, because of broad weakness in financial stocks but also due to investors’ concerns over the firm’s role in 1MBD scandal. Goldman also tends to underperform its peers in rocky markets because of its outsize trading business because of less transparency about its underlying earnings.
The only other major bank trading below book is Citigroup, a bank with returns on equity substantially lower than Goldman’s, at 9.6% in the latest quarter, compared with 13.1% for Goldman. Citi’s stock was off 3.2% Tuesday to $62.53, well below its book value of $72.88 a share as of the end of September.
Citi has traded below book more often than its peers in recent years because of its low returns and because it has greater exposure to volatile international markets.
Morgan Stanley on the other hand, was off 3% Tuesday at $43.10, trading at just a small premium to its book value of $40.67.
At $191.36, Goldman’s stock is just above the bank’s tangible book value of $186.62 a share. Tangible book is considered a hard measure of shareholder equity because it excludes goodwill and other intangibles. It is often viewed as a conservative proxy for liquidation value.
Goldman also has a rock-bottom price/earnings ratio, trading for less than eight times projected 2018 earnings of about $25 a share, the lowest P/E ratio among major financial stocks.
All of these factors combined make up for disquieting signs of how investors see the outlook of Goldman under its new CEO David Solomon.